More like “Impressed Itself”
Friday, June 27th, 2008Ok, so my wife and I have been test driving NBC’s new gimmick TV show, Fear Itself. The promo is that they’ve tapped some semi-named horror film directors to direct one-hour mini-movies, so each episode is directed by a different director and each is a self-contained short film. As you might assume from the title, they’re supposed to be scary…supposed being the operative word here.
After two episodes, the show feels more like the directors trying to entertain their own whims rather than create and spin engaging thrillers. In the case of last night’s episode–directed by John Landis and starring Maggie Lawson and James Roday of Psych fame (both of whom I find tremendously entertaining on their regular gig, which also might be my favorite series currently in production)–it felt more like Landis just mailed it in. Like he sent a first year film school intern to do his job under Landis’s name. The dialog was clunky, the performances were anything but genuine or believable (particularly from the supporting cast). It’s almost offensive how dumb these directors must think the audience is if they think they can revert to the same old gags and gimmicks that every would-be horror director has used since the dawn of the the talkie. I expected much more from Landis, who has to his credit such creep-outs as An American Werewolf in London and Michael Jackson’s Thriller (granted that one isn’t really scary, but at least well made).
Pile onto this pile of debris the uber-lame “twist” endings that they’re all trying to pull off and you have the makings of a world-class flop fest spread out over the course of the summer weeks. For example, in Landis’s episode, Lawson’s character is about to marry Roday’s character (aptly named Carlos…because when I see James Roday I immediately think Latino…??). Minutes before the ceremony, Lawson receives a mysterious note by way of her bride’s maid, who received it from the hard-of-hearing priest (played by William B. Davis, best known as Cancer Man from the X-Files), who received it from a mysterious woman in a red head scarf. The note warns Lawson that her soon-to-be-husband is a serial killer.
Well, since the authenticity of this note and the validity of its contents certainly can’t be questioned–ya know, considering the certainty of the source and all–she immediately goes into “flip out” mode and almost calls off the wedding.
Long story short, she goes through with the wedding, proceeds to suspect her new husband, who has suddenly turned into over-the-top-I-might-be-a-serial-killer-man complete with sinister laugh, and the two ultimately end up back in the church, in the confessional (each in their own booth), for the big reveal and final showdown. After much whining and whimpering on Lawson’s part, and much pseudo-sinisterness from Roday, it’s time for the big twist, which is…
Lawson is the serial killer. The note was meant for Carlos (Roday).
Now, you’re missing the full impact of this ridiculous turn of events because there’s much context that you have to understand in order to really get how lame and incoherent this was, but you get the idea.
So needless to say, Fear Itself is a definite must-miss, unless you’re hoping to practice up on your MST3K chops. I’m not impressed, and judging from the two episodes I’ve seen, maybe the show’s whole existence is little more than an exercise in self-congratulations on the part of the directors (or a thinly veiled insult to viewers who the directors assume aren’t smart enough to tell the difference).

